Sunday, August 12, 2012

Re: Elements of Martial Law

Regarding Ex parte Milligan

My friend Dr. Lowell Becraft ("Larry" expressed his concern that so many PNJ's  (Patriot Nut Jobs - I call them PMM's or Patriot Myth Mongers) complain that the US operates under martial law.  He wrote:

"In the case of  Ex parte Milligan, 71 U.S. 2 (1866), the Supremes were required to determine what constituted “martial law,” and in essence the Court concluded that it was essential that an army be in the field (meaning the locality where martial law prevails) and that the courts be closed because of the chaos. That case may be read here:      http://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/71/2/case.html.  Where I live, there is no army in the field, and our courts are open. In fact, I know of no place in America where an army is in the field, and anarchy is so prevalent that the courts must be closed. "

I, Bob, responded:

The courts do seem open, but to many they have become meaningless as tools of obtaining justice/redress because
 
    1.        Most don’t know the law or procedure
    2.      Most cannot afford legal counsel
    3.      Court and transcript and advocacy/case worker fees have become so exorbitant that most cannot afford them
    4.      Judges seem to favor lawyered litigants over pro se litigants
  
In other words, for most, courts have effectively become NOT open.  That is one reason so many have showed up in the field.

I am unusual.  Because I don’t work, I actually have the discretionary time for studying law and procedure, but even I would have a terrible time facing off against an experienced attorney.

THE COURTS ONLY SEEM OPEN.

Larry:   "But not because of martial law."

Bob:   "Then why?"

Larry:   "The best description is that it is a power structure that protects the powerful; but it is not martial law. "

Bob:   "Doesn’t that equal “martial law?”  The powerful remain protected by militant force against the non-powerful who have, as a consequence, no say in government except to the extent the powerful allow?"

Larry:   "Read the case:  http://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/71/2/case.html.We have lots of people that now believe we have martial law. When the real thing comes along, there will be no resistance because people thought it had already arrived."

Bob:   "I have always visualized martial law as evidenced by soldiers patrolling the streets.  Who needs them with bomb-dropping drones patrolling the skies?"

Larry:  "Excellent point, and drones may very well replace soldiers.
"

Now, I respond more fully, taking the time to honor the Ex parte Milligan opinion Dr. Becraft cited above.

 

The opinion in
Ex parte Milligan - 71 U.S. 2 (1866) makes the most excellent point that in martial law, military tribunals, not the judicial courts, try people accused of a crime in the jurisdiction of the military.  It also points out the process for using writ of error to appeal denial a petition for writ of habeas corpus, and the fact that the US must timely indict/present or discharge the prisoner.  It makes apparent the fact that only Congress can authorize the military to arrest and try folks in some territory of the US during insurrection/war/rebellion, and that the right to trial by jury always exists. It shows that grand juries must indict/present except in cases arising among military or militia forces during war or public danger. 

And, I rather enjoyed the Chief Justice's instruction about the meaning of certain legal terms including cause and suit, and the fact that an ex parte habeas proceeding constitutes a cause/suit of the prisoner against the captor, typically some agent or agency of the Government.  I also appreciated the Court's opinion that Congress, not the President, has final say over empowering the President to suspend of the right of petition for writ of habeas corpus in times of publicly dangerous national emergency. The Chief Justice poignantly penned:

"The suspension of the writ does not authorize the arrest of anyone, but simply denies to one arrested the privilege of this writ in order to obtain his liberty... It was the manifest design of Congress to secure a certain remedy by which anyone deprived of liberty could obtain it if there was a judicial failure to find cause of offence against him... authority was given to the judges out of court to grant relief to any party who could show that, under the law, he should be no longer restrained of his liberty... The power of punishment is alone through the means which the laws have provided for that purpose, and, if they are ineffectual, there is an immunity from punishment, no matter how great an offender the individual may be or how much his crimes may have shocked the sense of justice of the country or endangered its safety. By the protection of the law, human rights are secured; withdraw that protection and they are at the mercy of wicked rulers or the clamor of an excited people. "

Thus, must the prisoner who evades summary execution wait out the term of the emergency for restoration of the right  to petition the court to issue the writ so that the prisoner might prosecute the cause of liberty before the court against the captors.  And at that time, the court has the legal duty, not the prerogative, to grant the writ and order the release of the prisoner if the Government cannot show legal merit under the Fourth Amendment for the detention.  And that means, under the law, that the Grand Jury sitting after the capture must indict or present against the prisoner, or the court must order the prisoner's release.



My Favorite Excerpt from Ex Parte Milligan

Every actual and wanna-be Citizen should read and embrace this, my favorite excerpt from Ex Parte Milligan, for it illustrates the central core motive behind the Colonist's rebellion against the British Crown, and every rebellion against authority before or since.

Page 71 U. S. 118-121

The controlling question in the case is this: upon the facts stated in Milligan's petition and the exhibits filed, had the military commission mentioned in it jurisdiction legally to try and sentence him? Milligan, not a resident of one of the rebellious states or a prisoner of war, but a citizen of Indiana for twenty years past and never in the military or naval service, is, while at his home, arrested by the military power of the United States, imprisoned, and, on certain criminal charges preferred against him, tried, convicted, and sentenced to be hanged by a military commission, organized under the direction of the military commander of the military district of Indiana. Had this tribunal the legal power and authority to try and punish this man?

No graver question was ever considered by this court, nor one which more nearly concerns the rights of the whole people, for it is the birthright of every American citizen when charged with crime to be tried and punished according to law. The power of punishment is alone through the means which the laws have provided for that purpose, and, if they are ineffectual, there is an immunity from punishment, no matter how great an offender the individual may be or how much his crimes may have shocked the sense of justice of the country or endangered its safety. By the protection of the law, human rights are secured; withdraw that protection and they are at the mercy of wicked rulers or the clamor of an excited people. If there was law to justify this military trial, it is not our province to interfere; if there was not, it is our duty to declare the nullity of the whole proceedings. The decision of this question does not depend on argument or judicial precedents, numerous and highly illustrative as they are. These precedents inform us of the extent of the struggle to preserve liberty and to relieve those in civil life from military trials. The founders of our government were familiar with the history of that struggle, and secured in a written constitution every right which the people had wrested from power during a contest of ages. By that Constitution and the laws authorized by it, this question must be determined. The provisions of that instrument on the administration of criminal justice are too plain and direct to leave room for misconstruction or doubt of their true meaning. Those applicable to this case are found in that clause of the original Constitution which says "That the trial of all crimes, except in case of impeachment, shall be by jury," and in the fourth, fifth, and sixth articles of the amendments.

The fourth proclaims the right to be secure in person and effects against unreasonable search and seizure, and directs that a judicial warrant shall not issue "without proof of probable cause supported by oath or affirmation."

The fifth declares "that no person shall be held to answer for a capital or otherwise infamous crime unless on presentment by a grand jury, except in cases arising in the land or naval forces, or in the militia, when in actual service in time of war or public danger, nor be deprived of life, liberty, or property without due process of law."

And the sixth guarantees the right of trial by jury, in such manner and with such regulations that, with upright judges, impartial juries, and an able bar, the innocent will be saved and the guilty punished. It is in these words:

"In all criminal prosecutions the accused shall enjoy the right to a speedy and public trial by an impartial jury of the state and district wherein the crime shall have been committed, which district shall have been previously ascertained by law, and to be informed of the nature and cause of the accusation, to be confronted with the witnesses against him, to have compulsory process for obtaining witnesses in his favor, and to have the assistance of counsel for his defence."

These securities for personal liberty thus embodied were such as wisdom and experience had demonstrated to be necessary for the protection of those accused of crime. And so strong was the sense of the country of their importance, and so jealous were the people that these rights, highly prized, might be denied them by implication, that, when the original Constitution was proposed for adoption, it encountered severe opposition, and, but for the belief that it would be so amended as to embrace them, it would never have been ratified.

Time has proven the discernment of our ancestors, for even these provisions, expressed in such plain English words that it would seem the ingenuity of man could not evade them, are now, after the lapse of more than seventy years, sought to be avoided. Those great and good men foresaw that troublous times would arise when rulers and people would become restive under restraint, and seek by sharp and decisive measures to accomplish ends deemed just and proper, and that the principles of constitutional liberty would be in peril unless established by irrepealable law. The history of the world had taught them that what was done in the past might be attempted in the future. The Constitution of the United States is a law for rulers and people, equally in war and in peace, and covers with the shield of its protection all classes of men, at all times and under all circumstances. No doctrine involving more pernicious consequences was ever invented by the wit of man than that any of its provisions can be suspended during any of the great exigencies of government. Such a doctrine leads directly to anarchy or despotism, but the theory of necessity on which it is based is false, for the government, within the Constitution, has all the powers granted to it which are necessary to preserve its existence, as has been happily proved by the result of the great effort to throw off its just authority.

All of this means that Government employees must remember the purpose for their existence as part of Government.  They exist because the LAST government didn't heed its responsibilities to the people, so the people rebelled and established a new government to replace the old one.  They should remember this because it could happen again and again and again till people start becoming sublimely ethical and need no government.  It seems axiomatic that all governments eventually become corrupt and self-destructive through abuse of the governed who inexorably rebel or subject the government to external attack and dissolution.

War Powers, Trading with the Enemy, and Dilution of Rights


Neither the foregoing excerpt nor any thing else in the Ex parte Milligan opinion or dicta deals with the question of how to hold tyrants/gerps accountable for their torture and abuse of Citizens under color of law.  I an only suppose from their silence on the obvious point  that Citizens must do it by whatever means they find least dangerous and most expedient.  After all, not everybody like Milligan whom a Military Commission orders to die manages to survive the ordeal.  If one shall survive, one should do so in the first place by evading detection and capture as a rebel.  The American Revolution loudly exclaimed the question of a people's or an individual's right to rebel against an evil oligarchy -they, and we, have every right to do so.  The undaunted power of the present US Government makes it virtually impossible to do so, even against oligarchies operating inside it or adjacent to it or in control of it surreptitiously or under color of law. 

Now, how does the Citizenry convince the FBI of the necessity to hunt down and excise Gerps as its first order of business, senior to all other orders?  After all, the FBI has no moral authority to act against citizens who have legitimate unresolved complaints against Gerps, gerpitude, and other loathesome acts or actors of ommission or malfeasance in Government.  But that does not stop the FBI from acting against those Citizens, as far as I can see.

Even in the case of the Civil War, on which the Ex parte Milligan issue hung, many question the constitutional authority of Lincoln to prosecute that war against states who merely exercised their God-given right to secede from the union for the Northern States' and President's violation of the very contract that united them.  In essence the Civil War might have amounted to no more or less than the Battle of Hastings on a grand scale, where the Norman King William the Bastard murdered the King of England, with nephew and son, then simply stole the land of England and made it into a Norman province.

I have read provisions in the Florida Constitution that show the bootprint of the US Government in the wake of the Civil War - abortions like the loyalty oath (see below), the elimination of Grand Jury power to investigate all purported crimes and misdemeanors instead of merely capital crimes, elimination of the provision elucidating the right of the people to alter or abolish their form of government by whatever means they deem expedient, and forcing universal adult male suffrage on the state without regard to elector competence.

And many Citizens today complain that the Trading with the Enemy Act of 1917 and War Powers Act of 1933have imposed perpetual martial law on the people of the rebel states of the Civil War era, and that such law stands in force today.

According to 
this site, Gene Schroder explained the War Powers Act this way:

“Once the government gains ‘emergency’ power, it is reluctant to relinquish that power. During the Wars of 1812, 1847, 1861, 1917 and 941, the ‘emergency war powers’ were gradually and insidiously defined. However, on March 9, 1933, our government declared a National Emergency and, based on the public’s ignorance and the complacency, took permanent control of the people. Since March 9, 1933, the United States has remained in a continuous state of declared National Emergency. Since that time, the American people have lost their rights to government, and these rights have not been restored. The American government now claims the power of right, and rules the people by Statute – not the Constitution – in all cases. Under emergency powers, government can do whatever it deems ‘necessary’. The courts change from protectors of the people’s unalienable Rights to enforcers of the government’s statutes.

"However, if the ‘national emergency’ were ended, government abuse and injustice would also end. When the American people demand that congress end the ‘national emergency’ they will restore the U.S. Constitution, and regain their rights, freedom and property…”
And Al Adask wrote that the Trading with the Enemy Act of 1917, which allowed Government to tax foreigners to prevent them from buying American war materiel, has remained in force through the actions of each successive American President.  The presidents keep creating/declaring national emergencies (e.g., Korean War , VietNam War, Balkans War, Iraq War, Afghanistan War, War on Drugs, to justify it.  Adask wrote:

“The ‘President’s’ role in ending the national emergency is crucial because, although congressional approval was required to initially grant the emergency powers to the executive, once these those virtually absolute powers were granted, no one but the almighty President Dictator himself could return them. In other words, if every representative and senator in congress voted unanimously to end the national emergency, the vote would carry as much weight as if they had voted to end aging, gravity and death.  Just as the people in the Bible once insisted on having a King (and came to regret it), the 1933 congress also created an American ‘King’. And so long as that ‘King’ rules, we shall regret it because we are all relegated to status somewhat like a POW… End the national emergency and almost every ‘alphabet-agency’ will simply disappear since they have no constitutional foundation. OSHA, FDA, FCC, CIA, FBI, FTC, NASA, TVA and even the IRS will be gone…”

I suppose I don't need to bring up the Patriot Act which allows arrests, incarcerations, and suspension of Habeas Corpus rights for "domestic terrorism"  at the whim of the Executive Branch employees like FBI agents, without a court order.

These various acts limiting the rights of people and giving unconscionable power to government operatives, in concert with breaches of the 2nd Amendment right to keep and bear arms, and numerous court orders suppressing the right to publish and sell opinions on taxation powers and rights, all operate as a civil substitute for martial law.  And, the FBI, federal Marshals, Internal Revenue Criminal Investigation Division, Department of Homeland Security, Federal Emergency Management Agency, Drug Enforcement Agency, etc provide the muscle and arms (including drones) to back that power.  What need does America have for the military to suppress insurrection/rebellion when civil authority has such muscle?

The Florida Constitution on Martial Law and Rights


The process of presenting or indicting does not appear obvious from the opinion, but the Florida Constitution does.  It subordinates the military to civilian power.  Thus, while the Legislature could empower only military personnel to make arrests, civilian authority also make them.  But we know from history that powerful military rulers often ignore civilian authority and do as they please, killing or imprisoning whomever they consider a threat to their power and organization.

That's just one problem with "spy in the sky" drones.  We the people haven't a clue who owns that drone.  Do we-the-people of the nation or a state have the right to shoot down a drone as an enemy aircraft, even if the US has declared no war against anyone including US rebels?  Eventually the populace might develop inexpensive drone technology and deploy it just for the purpose of killing spy drones that fly too high for the naked eye to see them.  Do Citizens have the right to destroy the means by which government and non-government entities violate their privacy rights?  Must the citizens bring that issue to a court of the very government doing the spying?

And what if the Exexutive Branch (military or otherwise) surreptitiously subsumes civilian authority including sheriffs, police, and judicial courts (WITHOUT informing the people generally and publicly)?   In such a situation, normal sheriffs and police patrol the countryside and cityscape, apparently normal judges and clerks rule the courts, but they follow dictates of rulers hidden from the people.  Does the non-declaration of war or martial law prohibit assertion of martial law according to the Law of Nations?

My point:  many citizens argue that for all practical purposes precisely that has happened when they cannot get just rulings, as in income tax crime prosecutions, evidenced by better than 95% DOJ successes.  That makes it seem that the judges collude with US Attorneys to let the IRS win those cases.  It also indicates broad disagreement with the meaning or constitutionality of the tax code, not mere flouting of the law by the citizenry.  Such an enormous margin of victory for the DOJ  signifies collusion/corruption in the courts, or a condition of martial law where the courts operate by loyalty to some rules or code other than the plain words of the Constitution.

Let me drive this point home with some excerpts from the Florida Constitution regarding the loyalty oath, treason, privacy, courts, and martial law:

    Article I

    SECTION 7. Military power.—The military power shall be subordinate to the civil.

    SECTION 15. Prosecution for crime; offenses committed by children.—
    (a) No person shall be tried for capital crime without presentment or indictment by a grand jury, or for other felony without such presentment or indictment or an information under oath filed by the prosecuting officer of the court, except persons on active duty in the militia when tried by courts martial.
    (b) When authorized by law, a child as therein defined may be charged with a violation of law as an act of delinquency instead of crime and tried without a jury or other requirements applicable to criminal cases. Any child so charged shall, upon demand made as provided by law before a trial in a juvenile proceeding, be tried in an appropriate court as an adult. A child found delinquent shall be disciplined as provided by law.

    SECTION 16. Rights of accused and of victims.—
    (a) In all criminal prosecutions the accused shall, upon demand, be informed of the nature and cause of the accusation, and shall be furnished a copy of the charges, and shall have the right to have compulsory process for witnesses, to confront at trial adverse witnesses, to be heard in person, by counsel or both, and to have a speedy and public trial by impartial jury in the county where the crime was committed. If the county is not known, the indictment or information may charge venue in two or more counties conjunctively and proof that the crime was committed in that area shall be sufficient; but before pleading the accused may elect in which of those counties the trial will take place. Venue for prosecution of crimes committed beyond the boundaries of the state shall be fixed by law.
    (b) Victims of crime or their lawful representatives, including the next of kin of homicide victims, are entitled to the right to be informed, to be present, and to be heard when relevant, at all crucial stages of criminal proceedings, to the extent that these rights do not interfere with the constitutional rights of the accused.
   
    SECTION 18. Administrative penalties.—No administrative agency, except the Department of Military Affairs in an appropriately convened court-martial action as provided by law, shall impose a sentence of imprisonment, nor shall it impose any other penalty except as provided by law.
   
    SECTION 20. Treason.—Treason against the state shall consist only in levying war against it, adhering to its enemies, or giving them aid and comfort, and no person shall be convicted of treason except on the testimony of two witnesses to the same overt act or on confession in open court.

    SECTION 21. Access to courts.—The courts shall be open to every person for redress of any injury, and justice shall be administered without sale, denial or delay.

    SECTION 23. Right of privacy.—Every natural person has the right to be let alone and free from governmental intrusion into the person’s private life except as otherwise provided herein. This section shall not be construed to limit the public’s right of access to public records and meetings as provided by law.
 

    Article II

    SECTION 5. Public officers.—
    (a) No person holding any office of emolument under any foreign government, or civil office of emolument under the United States or any other state, shall hold any office of honor or of emolument under the government of this state. No person shall hold at the same time more than one office under the government of the state and the counties and municipalities therein, except that a notary public or military officer may hold another office, and any officer may be a member of a constitution revision commission, taxation and budget reform commission, constitutional convention, or statutory body having only advisory powers.
    (b) Each state and county officer, before entering upon the duties of the office, shall give bond as required by law, and shall swear or affirm:

    “I do solemnly swear (or affirm) that I will support, protect, and defend the Constitution and Government of the United States and of the State of Florida; that I am duly qualified to hold office under the Constitution of the state; and that I will well and faithfully perform the duties of   (title of office)   on which I am now about to enter. So help me God.”,

    and thereafter shall devote personal attention to the duties of the office, and continue in office until a successor qualifies.
    (c) The powers, duties, compensation and method of payment of state and county officers shall be fixed by law.
   
    SECTION 6. Enemy attack.—In periods of emergency resulting from enemy attack the legislature shall have power to provide for prompt and temporary succession to the powers and duties of all public offices the incumbents of which may become unavailable to execute the functions of their offices, and to adopt such other measures as may be necessary and appropriate to insure the continuity of governmental operations during the emergency. In exercising these powers, the legislature may depart from other requirements of this constitution, but only to the extent necessary to meet the emergency.

    Article V

    SECTION 1. Courts.—The judicial power shall be vested in a supreme court, district courts of appeal, circuit courts and county courts. No other courts may be established by the state, any political subdivision or any municipality. The legislature shall, by general law, divide the state into appellate court districts and judicial circuits following county lines. Commissions established by law, or administrative officers or bodies may be granted quasi-judicial power in matters connected with the functions of their offices. The legislature may establish by general law a civil traffic hearing officer system for the purpose of hearing civil traffic infractions. The legislature may, by general law, authorize a military court-martial to be conducted by military judges of the Florida National Guard, with direct appeal of a decision to the District Court of Appeal, First District.
*****************end of excerpts *******************


You might note from the above bold language some alarming realities. 

  • In a time of military emergency/war Congress can suspend the operation of the Constitution and its protections/guarantees.  In other words, the constitution contains the seeds of its own meaninglessness and destruction. 

  • All public officers swear "loyalty" (to support, protect, and defend) the constitutions AND GOVERNMENT.  That's like swearing loyalty to the enemy (government) when small or large oligarchies of Government Perpetrators of crimes (GERPS) have subsumed the normal, constitutional function of government into their private, personal super-government cliques. 

  • Even the provision defining treason uses terminology that makes it seem that the authors of the Constitution never considered the fact that some one oligarchy or many oligarchies might wrest lawful authority and operate certain government functions according to their whim rather than law or ideals of good government.  Doesn't taking control by stealth or flouting of constitutional obligations constitute a form of war or treason?

  • The Constitutions should never let public officers swear loyalty to "the Government" for that amounts to swearing loyalty to the clique or individuals running government....  In other words, the "good old boys network." 

  • And note that neither the Constitutions nor the laws of the US or the STATE punish the violation of one's loyalty oath.  What good is an oath of loyalty to support the constitution if no penalty applies to violations of the oath?  Did the authors intend the "God" punish the Gerp malefactors in the Hereafter?


A Citizen's Marching Orders

I say all of the points above mean one thing:  citizens must:
  • Become educated to understand the ideals of good government and Citizen responsibility - know the Constitution's guarantees (not grants) of rights and limits on government authority.

  • Learn and obey the ideals of Citizen Responsibility to keep an eye out for injustice, learn the law and court procedure, become disposing to use the law to resolve inequities/illegalities, and to abide by constitutional laws.

  • Become politically active to ensure the election and appointment of intelligent, educated people who will conform government to those ideals.

  • Associate with friends and neighbors to make local communities strong, organized, armed and trained, and politically active, as individuals and as communities.

  • Stand firm as Citizens in demanding that Government respect the Rights of the People.
  • Remain forever, rigorously vigilant to discover rogues and gerps in government and excise their behavior or them by normal political and legal means if possible, practical, and not dangerous; and otherwise excise them by any expedient means. 


In the final analysis, I want to say that if it looks, walks, quacks, and squirts like a duck, it IS a duck.  Clever people in Government do what they can to impose order and discipline on a people without appearing to do so - in other words, without calling in the Military or National Guard.  Why?  Because war costs so dearly in terms of life, time, money, lost productivity, other lost opportunity, and possible loss of power.  It generally takes a lot of abuse by government to rile a populace into open, widespread revolt.   

Government operatives do their best to label as insane, rabid criminals any and all who rebel against authority, even abusive, unconstitutional authority.  That alone functions as a kind of "martial law" in its effect of suppressing general rebellion.  And make no mistake - it can have every bit as unconstitutional, egregious, and wrong a nature as does unjust martial law by a corrupt and criminal government enterprise just trying to preserve its power and save the skins of its oligarchs.  Even a child would rightly question the possibility of obtaining reliable justice from courts that form part of the very fabric of government that abuses people under color of law.  Congress allocates half a billion dollars a year to pay secret cash awards to government employees who "do a good job."  Only a fool would believe that never includes judges, juries, and prosecutors who work to convict and imprison Citizens wrongly.

The nuance of difference between a corrupt system of prosecutors / courts and corrupt/abusive military authority matters not a whit to the targets of the abuse.  To the the victims, the power brokers have cut both classes of abusers from the whole cloth of corruption to make a garment of tyranny.  And that justifies any form and means of rebellion the victims may choose...

Provided, of course, the victims have not brewed their own witch's stew of "bubble bubble toil and trouble."   They can do that by embracing and perpetuating patriot myths that make people want to rebel just for the hell of it.  Or just so they can get out of engaging in gainful employment, paying taxes, mortgages, and credit card debts, becoming properly licensed under the law, or otherwise obeying practical and constitutional laws.

This point shows why I have articulated the Citizen's Marching Orders above.  They guide the Citizen in playing the proper role in an ordered, honest society.  And that requires that Citizens heed their own duties to learn, use, and obey the law BEFORE complaining much about Government.

Have you done that?  If not, get busy.  That job belongs to you and everyone else who would hold Government accountable for wrongdoing.  DO it.  Care for the telephone pole in your own eye before breaking your arm to point out the fleck of dust in your Government's eye.

--
Bob Hurt
P.O. Box 14712
Clearwater, FL 33766-4712
(727) 669-5511
Visit My Home Page  ·  Email Me  ·  Visit My Blog
Learn to Litigate with Jurisdictionary (Buy Now)
Stay informed with Lawmen E-letter (Subscribe Free Now)
Donate to my Law Scholarship Fund.

Phone App
reads tag

Monday, July 30, 2012

Gerp Awareness Code - How to Deal with Government Perpetrators of Crime


GERP AWARENESS CODE
  1. Gerp Meanings:
    1. Gerp means Government Employee Perpetrator of a Crime or Malfeasance of omission or commission. They give good government a bad name.
    2. Gerpness means one or more acts of crime or malfeasance perpetrated by a Gerp under color of law.  
    3. Gerpish means tendency to behave like a Gerp, committing criminal behavior or malfeasance while a Government employee.
    4. Gerpitude means the Gerpish character or nature of a Gerp. 
    5. Gerpdom means any pervasion or culture of Gerpness by two or more Gerps.
    6. Gerpectomy means the excision of Gerpness from a Gerp. 
    7. Gerpotomy means the separation of a Gerp from Government.
  1. Evil Oligarchy in Good Government.  A Gerp and the Gerp's enablers/supporters constitute an oligarchy that commits crimes/malfeasance under color of law (masquerading as lawful acts).  Such an oligarchy has no constitutional or legal basis for its existence, and each of the Gerp's acts or omissions that constitute crime or malfeasance betrays the oaths to support the constitutions, and operates as treason against those constitutions,  lawful government, and the People.
  2. Lawful Use of Sovereignty.  The People yield a measure of their sovereignty to Government only for the lawful/constitutional purposes of Government. They do not yield sovereignty to Gerps for the purpose of engaging in crimes or malfeasance under color of law.
  3. Live the Oath. Government employees must abide by their oaths to support, protect, and defend the constitutions, and must NOT obey unlawful orders or enforce unconstitutional laws.
  4. Self-Discriminating Government. Each Government employee must discriminate between lawful/constitutional and unlawful/unconstitutional laws/orders in each instance of a law or  order.
  5. Self-Policing Government.  Government and its employees have the obligation/duty to excise Gerps, criminal behavior, and malfeasance from Government.
  6. Seek Peaceful Redress. The governed, who suffer or observe some abuse from Gerps ought to try to achieve peaceful redress by every means possible before engaging in use of physical force, violence, insurrection, or rebellion to excise the Gerps from Government and bring them to justice.
  7. Discriminate between Solutions.  A huge gulf exists between excising a Gerp from government (justified) and rebelling against government in general (unjustified).  So, Citizens should discriminate between bad government and Gerps who give government a bad name through their crimes and malfeasance.
  8. Use the Courts when Possible. Citizens who suffer direct and palpable abuse from a Government employee might actually deserve the abuse, and often only a court of justice can sort it out.  Courts and prosecutors tend to believe Gerps over Citizens.  And, in many cases where a Citizen gets accused of a crime, the "system" pressures the Citizen to accept a plea-bargain-conviction rather than risk many years in prison, and that pressure has an unjust nature.   However, courts exist to redress injury, so a Citizen should prosecute a case against a Gerp through the administrative and justice courts whenever possible.
  9. Gradient Activism. Citizens should proceed in the following order to effect a Gerpectomy, then Gerpotomy - personal communication to the Gerp, Gerp's family, Gerp's friends and club members, Gerp's professional colleagues, Gerp's fellow workers, Gerp's employer, appointed/elected officers, private investigator and news media, internal affairs/regulatory agency,  administrative court, judicial court, law enforcers, prosecutors, grand jury, electors (campaigning), all citizens (rally, street demonstration), any other viable Choice the Citizen can contemplate, afford, and deem honorable and expedient. 
  10. Reporting Gerps Risky. Citizens risk injury (loss of life, limb, health, property, family, employment) by informing a Gerp of the intention to bring the Gerp to bay or to justice for the Gerp's crimes or malfeasance.  Gerps often protect themselves through violent retribution against such Citizens and their families and supporters.  One must carefully weigh the risks before informing the Gerp or the Gerp's seniors or associates of the Gerp's crimes and malfeasance.
  11. Learn and use the Law.  Citizens cannot properly scrutinize public servants without knowing and using the law and Citizen rights, including the rights to honest services from Government employees.  In general, learn the Constitutions of the US and State, Rules of Evidence, Rules of Court Procedure (on-line).  In an issue, study the common law, statutes, and court rulings (many on-line).  Learn to Shepardize a case.
  12. Get Media Involved. News Media outlets tend NOT to report Gerp crimes and malfeasance, particularly if the Gerp functions as a judge or prosecutor. However, a Citizen should send reports of Gerps' illegal behavior to the news media and encourage publication.
  13. Gerps Beg for Excision. A Gerp, by engaging in criminal behavior or other malfeasance under color of law, virtually begs, thereby, for his own summary excision from government or the planet by any expedient means that the Constitution does not prohibit, particularly in view of the danger to the Citizen of bringing the matter to public attention non-anonymously.
  14. If smoke, then fire.  Typical Gerps commit a variety of crimes and develop patterns of criminal behavior and malfeasance.  Therefore, Citizens should pool their resources to hire private investigator(s) to dig into the financial and other affairs of real or suspected Gerps.
  15. Sunshine, the best disinfectant.  Citizens should try to expose Gerp crimes and malfeasance through blogs, news media, flyers, etc.
  16. Physical Force the Last Resort.  Citizens should not resort to physical force or violence against the Gerp except as a last resort after all other practical means have failed repeatedly, for it nearly always risks the following:
    1. It might have an unjust nature because of misunderstanding of facts and law;
    2. It might not work to stop the Gerp's crimes/malfeasance;
    3. It nearly always puts the Citizen and the Citizen's family in trouble with the Government, at great risk of consequential personal loss.
  17. Evil Laws against Excision. A person injured by a Gerp under color of law has no moral obligation to heed any law against Citizen retribution against or excision of the Gerp. 
  18. Action Obligatory. Citizens who fail to take determined, lawful action to excise Gerpness and Gerps from Government thereby invite the trouble that Gerps mete out to them.
  19. Sincerity is the key to the Kingdom of Heaven. Reason, logic, and common sense should dictate how to deal with a Gerp and Gerpness.  One should always do the right thing under the circumstances.  
  20. Catch more flies with honey. Citizens ought to acknowledge a job well done by Government Employees, and laud their extraordinarily ideal performances.  This can inspire and motivate slackers and Gerps to perform their duties honorably and diligently.
  21. Gerps need Citizen help.  Gerps might have perverse pleasure addictions to drugs, alcohol, sex, etc, that they cannot control.  They might suffer from PTSD because of the rigors or philosophic inconsistencies of the system of government or justice.  Some Mafia or other crooked agent might have threatened the Gerp or a loved one with injury or exposure.   Citizens owe it to society to become alert to behaviors that earmark such troubles, expose it publicly, and insist the Gerp gets professional help to correct the misbehavior.  
  22. Sensible Suffrage.  Citizens should remain aware that their fellow Citizens who do not have sufficient intelligence, general education, moral and ethical responsibility, knowledge of the ideals of good government, or integrity, simply cannot and will not make prudent decisions regarding government, and they will encourage Gerpitude.  Therefore, responsible Citizens should continually push for laws that deny suffrage to the irresponsible and criminal.


If You Believe You Have Witnessed Tyranny...

  1. Write a paragraph summarizing each act of tyranny
  2. For each such act list the points of the act that constituted tyranny and show or explain how you came to that conclusion.
  3. For each such act, list the laws that prohibited the act or made it a crime or unethical act.
  4. For each such act cite the behaviors of the victim that might have provoked it.
  5. For each such act cite what you or others could have done to prevent the tyranny from occurring.
  6. For each unjustified act of tyranny, list the persons with phone, email, mail address you could contact to make the tyranny stop or bring the Gerp to justice.
  7. Write up your observation as an affidavit and prepare formal complaints appropriate to each person on the above lists.
  8. Distribute the complaints with a cover letter demanding relief and remedy, in accordance with the Gerp Awareness Code.
  9. Form a Political Action Committee to devise viable solutions that leave you alive, solvent, free, and in good health.

Note:  You should publish this Gerp Awareness Code and all its Canons far and wide.  I might modify it from time to time, so check back occasionally for changes.  Feel free to comment below.

--
Bob Hurt
P.O. Box 14712
Clearwater, FL 33766-4712
(727) 669-5511
Visit My Home Page  ·  Email Me  ·  Visit My Blog
Learn to Litigate with Jurisdictionary (Buy Now)
Stay informed with Lawmen E-letter (Subscribe Free Now)
Donate to my Law Scholarship Fund.

Phone App
reads tag

Sunday, July 29, 2012

Gerps - Take them Out One by One? Review of Real Meaning.

FBI and Florida Agents Paid Me a Visit.

The other day I wrote something to the effect of "Gerps - Take them out one by one."  That caused concern to an FBI agent.  He paid me a visit yesterday and admonished me to tone down my rhetoric.  He said one might construe that statement as encouragement to engage in violence against government, a violation of federal law.  Well, frankly, I would not want some idiot MISCONSTRUE my words as some kind of "voices in my head" order to kill government employees.  So I write this commentary to address the issue and give the real meaning of my words to whoever will pay attention.

My Attitude Against Violence

I do not promote wanton, mindless violence against government.  In particular I promote a peaceable process of using every power outside of violence or physical force to manipulate government.

Do you get that?  DO NOT ENGAGE IN SUCH VIOLENCE AGAINST "GOVERNMENT."  DO NOT CONSTRUE THE ABOVE SUBJECT PHRASE AS ADVOCATING VIOLENCE AGAINST GOVERNMENT.

How To Deal With Gerps Lawfully

Instead, look at it the quoted statement about taking Gerps out as a suggestion to take a GERP ( Government employee who perpetrates crime under color of law) out for a beer or coffee or sandwich and talk to him about his behavior and the importance of correcting it so that you don't have to report him as a domestic terrorist to the FBI.  Oh, you didn't know Gerps are domestic terrorists?  Well get a clue.  They ARE domestic terrorists.  And they need straightening out.

Last night I woke up at 4:45 AM and lay there pondering this issue of straightening Gerps out.  How, precisely do you go about it?  I got a picture in my mind of visiting with the GERP pleasantly to find out how he sees his duties and job and relationship with government, bosses, and the people he serves.  I have theorized that if you can get to know someone, you can understand his pains and motives, and then you can empathize, and even love him.  If he knows this he might become receptive to a gentle encouragement.

I am not a Gerp or a domestic terrorist, but the FBI agent and his State law enforcer buddy paid me a visit and spoke gently and kindly to me, telling me calmly of their concerns.  I had to admit they had a valid point, so to avoid misinterpretation of my meaning with the subject phrase I volunteered to write this explanation.  So you see?  A gentle talk does some good to straighten out a potentially troublesome situation.

Well, here's the straightening principle.  You start of gentle and friendly-like, and then you gradually step up your efforts to understand and to inspire the Gerp to correct his errors or leave government. You exert no more implicit or actual pressure or encouragement than needed in order to make the point, UNLESS the Gerp has gone bezerk, such as on a pistol-whipping or shooting spree.  Then you do what you must to protect yourself and stop the berzerkness.  Theoretically, it's better to suffer a pistol whipping than death.

So anyway, you step up your efforts, adding more and more pressure that will convince the GERP to behave until the Gerp either behaves or disappears from Government.  It's that simple.

Now, in the process, you must use lawful means, for if you don't, you will become a target of abuse by the Gerp's buddies - the "good old boys network".  Sadly, even though you operate within the law (even unconstitutional law) so as to go gentle, some Gerps will flash-back against you or seek retribution against you for your efforts.  And that could leave you broke, injured, homeless, and dead.  After all, Gerps are in government.  So there will come a point when dealing with unresponsive Gerps that it becomes dangerous for you, and you must then call in the Government's own enforcers/internal affairs people to correct the Gerp.  Or you must come with a lot of people in a march or demonstration to let the Gerp and his buddies know that you mean business ant the misbehavior must stop.

Often, law enforcers will take the Gerp to task, punish him, excise him from government, and possibly imprison him.

What is a Gerp's Problem, Anyway?

To see this issue with crystal clarity, look at what the Gerp does.  The Gerp escapes from the chains of the Constitution and, under color of law, that is while pretending legitimacy, the Gerp does behavior that the Constitutions do not permit Government to do.  The Gerp thereby BETRAYS THE TRUST the people placed in him when he swore his loyalty oath to support the Constitution.  He stops supporting the Constitution and establishes a tiny Outlaw Oligarchy withing the construct of and masquerading as legitimate government.  He has become the most treacherous of all criminals.  He has engaged in war against the Constitutions.

You, a Citizen and elector, also swore an oath to support the Constitutions.  So you have the DUTY to take the Gerp to task.  YOU MUST eliminate this Criminal Outlaw Oligarchy by whatever means you deem expedient.  The Gerp naturally will not want you to do this, so the Gerp will resist.  That's why you should report the Gerp to various entities in and out of government.  A great statesman once said "Sunshine is the best disinfectant."

Do Constitutions Protect Me?

But what if all of your efforts simply create more danger for you?  What if the Gerp and his buddies abuse you to no end?  What shall you do then?  Will the Constitutions Protect you?

Sadly, no they won't.  That's your job. Government only takes on that job to the extent its agents please to take it on.  Many Americans suffer loss of life, limb, property, and pursuit of happiness because government does not protect them from crooks, and many such crooks happen to be GERPS.

Well then pay heed to The original declaration of Independence and Declaration of Rights of all state Constitutions, and the Tenth Amendment.

CONSTITUTION OF USA -10th Amendment - The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.

CONSTITUTION OF FLORIDA 1838 Article I Section 2. That all political power is inherent in the people, and all free governments are founded on their authority, and established for their benefit; and, therefore, they have, at all times, an inalienable and indefeasible right to alter or abolish their form of government, in such manner as they may deem expedient.

DECLARATION OF INDEPENDENCE - We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.--That to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed, --That whenever any Form of Government becomes destructive of these ends, it is the Right of the People to alter or to abolish it, and to institute new Government, laying its foundation on such principles and organizing its powers in such form, as to them shall seem most likely to effect their Safety and Happiness. Prudence, indeed, will dictate that Governments long established should not be changed for light and transient causes; and accordingly all experience hath shewn, that mankind are more disposed to suffer, while evils are sufferable, than to right themselves by abolishing the forms to which they are accustomed. But when a long train of abuses and usurpations, pursuing invariably the same Object evinces a design to reduce them under absolute Despotism, it is their right, it is their duty, to throw off such Government, and to provide new Guards for their future security.

Clearly, the founders of our nation and states felt strongly that people can take the law into their own hands as a consequence of intolerable government abuse.  I have read no grant of power in the Constitution that permits GERPS to function in government unmolested.  But I have read laws that forbid violence against Government, rebellion, and the like.  I believe anyone who reads the foregoing founding documents, specifically the quoted sections above can see that it means no constitutional law may forbid rebellion against GERPS in government.

Every inhabitant of the land has the right to interpret the Constitution for himself.  Barack Obama did that when he ran for President while not enjoying natural born citizen status.  Therefore, why shouldn't you?  You could look to the various panel courts in the land for guidance.  Unfortunately when you see non-unanimous opinions that screams pretty loudly "We justices don't know what the law means," so you might as well interpret it for yourself.

FBI:  Do You Violate Your Oaths to Support, Protect, and Defend the Constituion?

And that means NO FBI agent or other officer of government ought to enforce an unconstitutional law or obey an illegal order, and every government employee has the duty as a citizen to discriminate between legal and illegal laws, orders, and court rulings, and to refuse to support those that violate the constitution's safeguards of people's rights and restrictions on government power.

Every FBI agent with half a brain ought to know and understand these principles.  So I feel doubly glad that the FBI agent who visited me this week showed respect while asking me to watch how I express these sticky points lest some idiot with a machine gun misconstrue my message.

And yet, in the final analysis, Government is all about enforcing will with physical force and threat of violence.  So when an irresolvable dispute between people and government arises, the people have the inalienable, indefeasible right to use any means they deem expedient to alter or abolish their form of government.  That remains especially true when abolishing the EVIL OUTLAW OLIGARCHY established by one or more GERPS.

Points of Contention or Agreement

To all FBI Agents  and righteous inhabitants of America, if you take exception to or question the words, reasoning, or logic I have presented in this commentary, please write me with your comments.  I want the FBI to know I am a man of good will.  I also want the FBI to know that the good will of every American has a justifiable limit at the leading edge of abuse by one or more GERPs. 

Appeal for Government Agents to Think Straight

You in the FBI would do well to make excision of Gerps and their crimes from government your number one objective.

Why?  A citizen thief or killer injures only that one victim.  A GERP injures every inhabitant in the territory in question by depriving the people of honest government.  For that reason, the people ought to have such power that all government employees at least respect, and maybe fear, that power.  But people should not fear their government. 

Unfortunately, millions of Americans do, because of widespread abuse by GERPs.  And eventually that fear might spark general rebellion.

Remain Lawful

Back to the initial issue, "Take Gerps out one by one" means focus your attention on only one GERP at a time, and work assiduously at correcting him or removing him from government, LAWFULLY.  In the process do not put yourself unduly in harm's way.  Try to rely on the Government's own internal correction systems to correct and punish the Gerp.  Go outside that only if your repeated efforts have failed, or if pursuing the matter becomes dangerous.  DO NOT ENGAGE IN VIOLENT RETRIBUTION AGAINST LAWFUL GOVERNMENT EMPLOYEES.

Discovering Fact, Applying Law

People find it difficult to remain unbiased and to inquire thoroughly so the relevant facts can come to light in a dispute,  They suffer from ignorance of the law.  So, our founders of our government established court systems to resolve controversies between people.  Wise and experienced judges over centuries developed rules of procedure for different kinds of court actions and rules of evidence for bring facts to light.  It takes considerable study to learn them, so most people don't learn them. Such people who litigate typically lose because they don't know the legal landscape or rules.

I have learned that in most controversies neither party sees the issues correctly or applies the law correctly.  So we let judges decide this according to the rules.

That fact reveals the biggest problem with taking the law into your own hands in any but the most dire emergency, In an irresolvable controversy  with  a presumed Gerp, one should refer the matter to an internal affairs group or administrative or judicial  court to iron out the facts and apply the law.  Then one should abide by the court's ruling.


The Proper Gradient

As my final point, I encourage you to consider the proper gradient or scale of applied pressure to use when dealing with Gerps.  I merely conjecture these.  Review them.  Adapt them only if they are true to you.  In the process be true to your moral and ethical convictions, but remain devoted to truth above all.  Start at the top item in the list and apply it.  If it works to correct the Gerp, go no further unless the law requires you to.

  1. Report GERP  felonies to a judge, law enforcer, prosecutor, grand juror, military officer of jurisdiction.
  2. If possible, hire a private investigator to expose the Gerps crimes and malfeasance fully.
  3. Then communicate with one or more of the following as needed to effect reform or removal of the Gerp:

  • The Gerp himself
  • The Gerp's friends and encourage them to convince the Gerp to reform
  • The Gerp's religious authority
  • The Gerp's professional and business associates
  • The Gerp's employer
  • News Media reporters
  • Internal Affairs or the equivalent professional regulation group
  • The police/sheriff/Marshal/US or State Attorney
  • File a lawsuit against the Gerp - seek ACLU assistance
  • Vote the Gerp out of office
  • Get a law enacted that sets up an automatic correction of the Gerp and others like him
  • Rally a group of people in lawful protest with news media presenIf
If all of these fail, use your best judgment and try to do what you think right.  If you violate a criminal statute, even an unconstitutional one, you put yourself and your loved ones in harm's way.

--
Bob Hurt
2460 Persian Drive #70
Clearwater, FL 33763-1925
(727) 669-5511
Visit My Home Page  ·  Email Me  ·  Visit My Blog
Learn to Litigate with Jurisdictionary (Buy Now)
Stay informed with Lawmen E-letter (Subscribe Free Now)
Donate to my Law Scholarship Fund.

Phone App
reads tag

Saturday, July 28, 2012

Fight the Foreclosure… or the Mortgage?

Mortgage Justice Group Meeting Talking Points – 28 July 2012

Fight the Foreclosure… or the Mortgage? (Education, Not LEGAL ADVICE)

Mortgagors need mostly to understand the predisposition of the court to go along with a foreclosure effort comes from these rights declarations

Florida Constitution, Article I, Declaration of Rights:

SECTION 2. Basic rights.—All natural persons, female and male alike, are equal before the law and have inalienable rights, among which are the right to enjoy and defend life and liberty, to pursue happiness, to be rewarded for industry, and to acquire, possess and protect property; except that the ownership, inheritance, disposition and possession of real property by aliens ineligible for citizenship may be regulated or prohibited by law. No person shall be deprived of any right because of race, religion, national origin, or physical disability.

SECTION 9. Due process.—No person shall be deprived of life, liberty or property without due process of law, or be twice put in jeopardy for the same offense, or be compelled in any criminal matter to be a witness against oneself.

SECTION 10. Prohibited laws.—No bill of attainder, ex post facto law or law impairing the obligation of contracts shall be passed.

SECTION 21. Access to courts.—The courts shall be open to every person for redress of any injury, and justice shall be administered without sale, denial or delay.

Redress of Lender / Mortgagee Injury

Lenders/Mortgagees lend their money to mortgagors who give mortgagees legal ownership of the realty purchased with that money until the mortgagor has discharged the note by paying in accordance with its terms.  Failure to pay injures the lender/mortgagee.  The court must give redress for the injury, and neither the legislature nor the court shall make any law impairing the obligations of the note and the mortgage which, in combination, constitute a contract.

Why Foreclosure Plaintiffs Win… Virtually Always

It's that simple.  SO … EVERY EFFORT to circumvent that redress such as by pointing to defects in the foreclosure process, will eventually meet with defeat UNLESS the foreclosure plaintiff so abuses due process as to anger the judge, who sends the plaintiff forth without day.  Typically, even when the defendant wins on some technicality, the bank plaintiff will repair the technical defects and refile or appeal, and THEN win.  That's how important Article I Section 21 becomes to Florida judges.  They have sworn an oath to support, protect, and defend the Constitutions, and mostly they try to comply. One might find violations of some law that will result in a fine or penalty against the mortgagee/plaintiff/plaintiff's agents.  But the borrower will still lose the house.

Mortgagors should ask: "Do attorneys commit malpractice who merely fight the foreclosure without contracting an expert to examine the mortgage for causes of action?"

How Aggressive Mortgagors Can Win

Find the Causes of Action against the Lender and Lender's Agents

Now, if the foreclosure victim or anybody with an upside down mortgage examines the mortgage for contract breaches, tortious conduct, and legal errors, that could change things.  All of those constitute injuries of the borrower by the lender or lender agents.  If the borrower can prove those injuries, such as loan application or appraisal fraud, the borrower now has right to access the court for redress of injury, and the right to justice.  The court will typically bend over backwards to give redress for genuine injury.  The mortgagor's attorney might show the causes of action to the mortgagee/assignee of the note and negotiate a settlement in the form of loan balance reduction, or house free and clear. Failing that, the attorney might litigate against the lender and the court, as a consequence of proof of injury and damages, might order redress in the form of loan balance reduction, house free and clear, legal fees and costs paid, and a cash award in the thousands to millions of dollars.

Negotiate A Financially Safe Exit

The mortgagor knows that it makes no sense to fight the lender/mortgagee if the fraud examination discloses no causes of action. Such mortgagors should prepare to leave the property in such a way as to avoid foreclosure and a consequent collapse of credit.

A loan mod makes no sense unless it constitutes a mere cram down of the loan balance to existing property value minus paid-in equity, and a going-rate of interest for a term suitable to the mortgagor. However, one can stop the foreclosure by asking for a loan mod.

Meanwhile, the mortgagor should make the property ready for sale, and put it on the market for the highest possible price, and settle for a short sale if necessary. In the end, if no sale becomes possible the mortgagor can lobby the lender for a keys-for-cash deal. In many if not most cases, the prudent mortgagor can save mortgage payments, add the keys-for-cash money, leave the house, rent for a while, and buy a house at auction or in a depressed community for cash on hand, free and clear. Any negotiated exist can minimize damage to the credit rating.

Summary and Conclusion

The foregoing realities should condition one's approach to dealing with mortgagees, either in or out of foreclosure.  It's better to be the dog than the dog meat.

Contact Bob Hurt NOW for info on Expert Mortgage Fraud Examination that could reveal causes of action that might get your house free and clear.

--
Bob Hurt
2460 Persian Drive #70
Clearwater, FL 33763-1925
(727) 669-5511
Visit My Home Page  ·  Email Me  ·  Visit My Blog
Learn to Litigate with Jurisdictionary (Buy Now)
Stay informed with Lawmen E-letter (Subscribe Free Now)
Donate to my Law Scholarship Fund.

Phone App
reads tag

Thursday, July 19, 2012

One Reason Maria Stays - a Dinner for Two Recipe

Here's one reason Maria stays with a scrufty old sailor man like me:

Menu

  • Honey-smoked Virginia ham slices slathered with southern-style Cardinal Mendoza cognac-raisin-butter sweet sauce
  • Sazon-seasoned snow peas sauteed in EVOO with red and orange sweet pepper slices
  • Creamed Idaho baking potatoes steamed with fresh garlic cloves and Florida sweet onion and mashed with butter, cream, salt, pepper
  • A delicate dry white vintage wine of choice.




Dinner for Two


  • Wine preparation- decant and set the decanter in ice to make it very cold.  Refrigerate the wine glasses.

  • Sauce preparation  - put 1/3 cup raisins in a mug or small sauce pan with 2 oz Cardinal Mendoza cognac mixed with 1 TBSP water and 2 TBSP corn syrup or granulated sugar to soak.  Shake in a pinch of salt.  Melt 2 TBSP butter and stir in 1/2 tsp cornstarch till no clumps remain.

  • Potatoes preparation - peel a whole medium Vidalia or Florida sweet onion and two Idaho baking potatoes.  Chop  the tip off of 3 or 4 fat cloves of fresh garlic.  Chop the onion into small pieces 1/4" square and the potato into 1/2" cubes.  Put these in a steamer and steam over water boiling a medium to medium-high heat for 20 minutes.  Use only enough water to last about 30 minutes - you should have half a cup left in the bottom of the pan.  Start with about 2 cups.  You will use this water for the mashed potatoes.

  • Snow Peas.  Sautee 1/3 to 1/2 pound snow peas and 2 small sweet peppers, sliced, in 1 tbsp each of extra virgin olive oil and butter, salt and pepper to taste, over low to medium heat.  Do not overcook and do not brown these.  Shake Complete Sazon seasoning to taste on the peas during cooking.  Add 2 tbsp dry white wine for additional flavor during last few minutes, and let it boil to reduction.  Toss the pan contents several times during cooking so as to cook all peas and peppers al dente or to desired crunch.

  • Sauce - set the sauce pan on medium-low heat to cook the raisins and reduce the alcohol.  It will boil quickly because of alcohol content.  Briskly stir in the butter/cornstarch mix.  Remove from heat

  • Potatoes - squish garlic cloves into potatoes, and pour the steamer contents into the bottom pan with heat turned off.  You will have some water in it.  Add half teaspoon salt and black pepper, and 1/4 to 1/2 cup cream, plus 2 to 4 tbsp butter to the pan, and mash by hand, stirring to thoroughly mix the contents.  Remove from burner as necessary to keep the mix from scorching.

  • Ham - heat  4 large slices of smoked honey-cured Virginia ham in the peas sautee pan at low heat, and flip at least once to get the ham hot.  Add a TBSP of water if needed to prevent drying.

  • Plating - Gob several spoonfuls of mashed potatoes on the plate and garnish with parsley, a dash of paprika, and a dollop of butter if desired.  Spoon on some of the snow pea mix.  Put one ham slice, and slather it with the sauce then do the same with the second slice on top of the first, offset a bit.  Make sure to get raisins on both slices.  Serve immediately with half a glass of very cold white wine.  If necessary, reheat the cooked items to keep them sufficiently hot for an enjoyable meal after plating.  Any excess sauce will make bread pudding or oatmeal even more delicious.

Enjoy


--
Bob Hurt
2460 Persian Drive #70
Clearwater, FL 33763-1925
(727) 669-5511
Visit My Home Page  ·  Email Me  ·  Visit My Blog
Learn to Litigate with Jurisdictionary (Buy Now)
Stay informed with Lawmen E-letter (Subscribe Free Now)
Donate to my Law Scholarship Fund.

Phone App
reads tag

Sunday, July 15, 2012

Lindsey Springer: 10th holds IRS exists solely under 26 CFR 601.101

While Lindsey Springer sits locked away for year and years and years, he, and his son outside of prison, assiduously study and promulgate pesky explanations about the IRS and tax code related to his conviction and appeal.

Lindsey has dissected and gutted the 10th Circuit ruling that left him in prison without a hint of sanity or legality.  Essentially, they have said the naked king has a nice coat on.

Lindsey needs a kind of expertise that you don't normally find in a lawyer's office.

Bob Hurt


-------- Original Message --------
Subject: 10th holds IRS exists solely under 26 CFR 601.101
Date: Fri, 13 Jul 2012 15:46:19 -0500
From: Lindsey Springer <gnutella@mindspring.com>


Lindsey Springer here hoping my words help you in some way understand this journey we are on to get rid of the IRS (although most have no problem with America saying "get rid of Obamacare") and replace it with something that will be strictly governed by whatever laws Congress writes and that we can all understand.  We need a Supreme Court that will protect our liberties and property rights when it comes to the imposition and levy of taxes when the procedure followed is not in accord with the Tax Laws and Treasury Regulations.  We can all agree we need to understand the structure of all agencies acting on behalf of the United States.  In my next thread I will reveal to you what an executive agency is under Federal Law and what is not.  Suffice it to say the Court would never have been able to switch penalty to tax had it addressed the problems with the IRS and its collection procedures or enforcement exercises.

On February 12, 2012, the 10th Circuit was faced with whether the existence of the IRS was a question of fact or matter of law.  Can you imagine the question even being subject to differing views?  (Does the FBI exist or not would be something similar).  We see them.  They are in are face before every movie we rent (FBI that is).  So what about the IRS.  What current statute of Congress allows them to exist in the first place?  What delegation of authority has authorized the an "agency" named IRS to act or take action on behalf of the Congress of the United States?

Now that America has learned the Supreme Court can be very divisive, it should be no surprise the Federal Courts below the Supreme Court get their inspiration from their 9 bosses devices.  The 10th Circuit in U.S. v. Hoodenpyle, U.S. App. Lexis 2290, ruled on February 12, 2012, that whether the IRS exists is not a question of fact but rather a question of law.  Hoodenpyle had sought a jury instruction on the IRS and the District Court declined his invitation.  The Court directed the Jury the IRS was an "agency" of the United States.  But are they really established by some law?

In my recent 10th Circuit appeals, the same three Circuit Judges Hoodenpyle drew, I drew, suspended my attorney for 1 year for claiming the IRS under 26 CFR 601.101(2000-2012) did not exist lawfully outside D.C. due to the second sentence of this procedural regulation that said "Within an internal revenue district the internal revenue laws are administered by a district director."  It is these words appearing in section 601.101 and elsewhere in Title 26 and properly promulgated substantive treasury regulations that are causing all the problems continuing to rely upon "internal revenue district" and "district director" when none have existed for 13 years.

It is no secret that all Internal Revenue Districts were abolished in 1999.  Likewise, all District Directors (officers) offices were also abolished and are now defunct so sayeth the 10th Circuit in its decision in the criminal case brought against me.  USA v. Springer, 444 F. Appx. 256, 261 (10th Cir. 2011).  The Hoodenpyle and Springer three 10th Circuit Judges (in Springer) cited Allnutt v. CIR, 523 F.3d 406, 408 n.1 (4th Cir. 2008) for the fact the district director offices no longer existed.  The 10th Circuit suggested the Restructuring and Reform Act of 1998 itself called for the President's Internal Revenue Districts and Secretary's District Director office delegations under 26 U.S.C. Section 7514 to be abolished.  Of course the Commissioner of Internal Revenue was directed to make a plan and he or she is not above the President (or is he or she).

Even if you were instructed to reorganize the IRS you would need to know what part of the IRS stayed the same and what part was changed.  To grasp that you would need to know where to start.  Where to start regarding this years IRS is a complete mystery.

The issue about the IRS comes down to two provisions of law and both America needs to grab a hold of and hold on tight.  My attorney relied upon 26 U.S.C. Section 7621 and the 9th Circuit's decision in U.S. v. Hughes, 953 F.2d 531, 536-542(9th Cir. 1992) where that Circuit Court of Appeals (one filing away from the Supreme Court) held the Secretary of the Treasury was authorized to act beyond Title 4, Section 72 limitations, due to the President's establishing "internal revenue districts" under 26 U.S.C. Section 7621.  No other reason was given and none other is to be found.

In Hoodenpyle, the 10th Circuit relied upon 31 U.S.C. Section 301(a)(creating the Department of Treasury), and 26 CFR Section 601.101 (without citing to any year as they did in their opinion with me about 26 CFR Section 1.6091-2) to say:

     "The Internal Revenue Service is a bureau within the Department of the Treasury under the immediate direction of the           Commissioner of Internal Revenue."

See 601.101 first full sentence.

The Commissioner is not the "Commissioner of THE Internal Revenue Service" or the "Commissioner of THE internal revenue" he is the "Commissioner of Internal Revenue."   He would be the "Commissioner" over all "internal revenue". The Second sentence in Section 601.101 reads as follows:

     "Within an Internal Revenue District the internal revenue laws are administered by a district director."

It is this 2nd sentence of Section 601.101 that you should zoom your cites in on.  In the 10th Circuits decision in my criminal appeal of their conviction of me, the same three Hoodenpyle Judges held all "internal revenue districts" were "now defunct." See U.S. v. Springer, 444 F.Appx. 256, 261 (10th Cir. 2011); citing to Allnutt v. CIR, 523 F.3d 406, 408 n.1 (4th Cir. 2008)

But they never addressed Section 601.101 EVER.  They also switched my indictment from failing to file a "tax return" under 26 U.S.C. Section 6091(b) to "any return" under Section 6091(a). Section 6091 is entitled Place for filing return.   Id. at 261.  By doing this the 10th Circuit was avoiding having to address where [you or] I was required to file Form 1040 and pay taxes on the income allegedly owed [by the Grand Jury] in very generic terms.  It would be good for you to take a look at Section 6091(b) and 6091(a) for yourself and see if you notice the difference.  I by no means am suggesting you not file or pay but just to understand for yourself the problem causes under the "rule of law" by the statutes and regulations continuing to direct you take action at a certain time and certain place and then the place does not exist.

The reason why you need to know where you are required to deliver or file your returns cannot be made more clear than recently in the Affordable Health Care decision by the Supreme Court which stated that "the requirement to pay is found in the internal revenue code and enforced by the IRS".   But where is it found and where did the IRS get mentioned in that Statute?   Now that question raised by that statement shows the problem.  This is why the Majority decision is simply more abra cadabra.  Section 6091 in my opinion does not require you to pay anything but merely to deliver your Tax Return Form according to the plethora of Federal Cases on the subject.  This shows the Court is aware of the problem with the law.

It is when you get to Section 6151 that this statute determines where and when you are required to pay taxes on income  and says such payment is due at the "the time and place for filing" your return.  This ties Section 6091's place to the place to pay under Section 6151.  The Supreme Court could not get any closer to this issue than the sentence quoted above ("the requirement to pay is found in the internal revenue code and enforced by the IRS") because they knew the "requirement to pay" is directed by Congress to the "district director" and that director no longer exists since 1999.

Now maybe America knows why they will not address tax issues when properly presented because they will be required to say what the law is and whether it is being implemented according to the wording and your due process rights.  Of course, switching a tax to a penalty is as ridiculous as switching a penalty to a tax while leaving it a penalty at the same time.  Does that make any sense?  Of course not.

Now, when the proper questions are not before them, the 10th Circuit decides the coast is clear and they can address Section 601.101 but only the first sentence.  Even that finding in Hoodenpyle directly conflicts with U.S. v. Horne, 714 F.2d 206, 207 (1st Cir. 1983):

     "Like the IRS's statement of procedural rules, 26 CFR Section 601.101, et seq. (1982)(NOTICE CITATION TO THE SPECIFIC       YEAR OF THE REGULATION?)...their purpose is to govern the internal affairs of the Internal Revenue Service.  THEY DO         NOT have the force and effect of law."  Einhorn v. Dewitt, 618 F.2d 347, 350 (5th Cir. 1980); see also Brafman v. U.S.
     384 F.2d 863, 865 (5th Cir. 1978)("invalidating an assessment not signed by the proper official in violation of binding           treasury regulations.")

So, the 10th Circuit says the IRS is a bureau within the Department of Treasury.  Section 601.101 does not make it so and in fact Section 601.101 suggests the IRS already exists by saying it "is" a "bureau."  Now we know FBI stands for Bureau and that Title 28, Section 531 established that bureau within the Department of Justice.   But what Statute created the IRS within the Department of Treasury?  No Court or Government Bureaucrat is willing to say.  Like anything wouldn't be easier than just to say the IRS was created by ?????.  I pray this turns into the birth certificate that won't go away.  In fact, lets say we are looking for the IRS's current birth certificate that allows them to be in the Country legally.  Everyone else must do it, why not the "IRS"?

Recently, the Tax Division claimed the IRS's delegation as an "agency" of the Secretary of the Treasury to issues summons under Section 7601 ("canvas internal revenue districts" for things to tax or seize) or Notice of Deficiencies under 6212, was Internal Revenue Manual ("I.R.M.") 1.2.43.9  This I.R.M. provision specifically refers to 26 CFR 301.6212-1(of course no year is cited) and that regulation delegates the authority Congress gave the Secretary of the Treasury at section 6212, to you guessed it, the district director of each internal revenue district.  26 CFR Section 301.7601-1 also delegates to the district director the Secretary's authority to canvas internal revenue districts regarding liens, levies, summons, and so forth.

The Government actually asked the 10th Circuit to "presume that proper delegation orders have been issued."  What is even more disturbing is that the "IRM does not have the force and effect of law." Curly v. U.S., 791 F. Supp. 52, 54 (E.D. New York, 1992), and its "procedures...are intended [only] to aid internal administration of the IRS.  THEY DO NOT CONFER RIGHTS ON TAXPAYERS."  In Re Carlson, 126 F.3d 915, 923 (7th Cir. 1997), Cert. Denied, 523 U.S. 1060 (1998).  The I.R.M. has no force of law.  U.S. v. Lockyer, 448 F.2d 417, 421 (10th Cir. 1971)  See also Poindexter v. CIR, 321 F. Appx. 721, 773 (10th Cir. 2009).

The Supreme Court said it best in Central Laborers Pension Fund v. Heinz, 541 U.S. 739, 748 (2004):

     "neither an unreasonable statement in the manual nor allegedly longstanding agency practice can trump a formal           regulation with the procedural history necessary to take on the force of law."

In LaSalle v. U.S., 437 U.S. 298, 316 (n. 18)(1978) the Supreme court explained:

     "the IRS does not enjoy inherent authority [to summons production of private papers of citizens]...it may exercise only           that authority granted by Congress."

I will devote my next email to the decision recently by the Supreme Court to change penalty to tax in the individual mandate regarding health insurance.  I would say that if the tax is an excise tax, as the Majority citing to Article I, Section 8, Cl. 1, suggested, begs the question what is the "activity" the excise is being placed upon?

You may be pondering the difference between the power to tax and the power to penalize.  The power to tax derives from the Constitution and the power to penalize is judicially created out of the Commerce Clause.

I would remind you that the 6th Circuit and 10th Circuit have held the Form 1040 is "divorced" from the requirement to file a U.S. Individual Income Tax Return. I wonder where the information about whether you own a health insurance contract is to be reported "as required by law"?

I pray God allows you to see through the trickery he has enshrined in the United States Tax Code and those who choose to support its expansion instead of demanding its demise.

God bless you, Lindsey Springer 7.4.12

=====================================================

Thank you so much for the support you have given us so far.  I pray that you are rewarded for your generosity, both in this life and the next.

PayPal:

Mailing address for donations or other inquiries (cash, or blank first name on checks):
_________  Springer
5147 S. Harvard, #116, Tulsa, OK  74135

Letters to Lindsey directly (no donations or packages):
Lindsey Springer, 02580-063
FCI Big Spring
1900 Simler Ave
Big Spring, TX  79720


Thanks,
Lindsey & Family